CostCost typeLevel of analysisRecurrence
PBP technical assistance contract, two Boston-based coordinators (2014), hired facilitators, translation and interpretation, printed multilingual ballots, materials and prizesDirect moneyOrganizationalRecurring
City staff time: Oversight Committee, Youth Council manager, department staff vetting eligibility and pricing proposals, BPS data officeStaff timeOrganizationalRecurring
Change Agent time: weekly after-school meetings for about eight weeks, 10 to 15 hours a month in 2014 and 8 to 10 in 2016, plus long journeys across the cityVolunteer and community timeIndividualRecurring
Steering Committee organisations and their youth representatives: rule-writing workshops, meetings, event mobilisation and outreachVolunteer and community timeOrganizational, IndividualRecurring
$1 million a year of capital money allocated by youth vote instead of through the City's own capital planningOpportunity costOrganizational, CommunityRecurring
City departments give up discretion over that $1 million and accept youth judgment on need, including on things staff felt they should already be fixingMental model surrenderedOrganizational, CulturalRecurring
Maker’s note · curator

No source gives a running cost figure: the PBP contract value, facilitator pay and staff hours are not documented, so the direct money row names the items without a number. The best-documented cost is the young people's time. Change Agents were asked for 10 to 15 hours a month in 2014 and 8 to 10 in 2016 on top of school, and both evaluations tie the cost of travel (two trains, City Hall downtown, meetings on school days) to attrition and to who could afford the deepest roles, which means the heaviest cost fell on youth from the outlying, high-need neighbourhoods the process meant to centre. The Steering Committee's cost shows in its attrition from 68 people to a handful. Political capital spent by the Mayor is not discussed in any source and is left out.

Guest book

Notes left on Costs.

No notes yet. Be the first to leave one on this node.